Defendant; evidence of mental condition admissible.
File HB1411 ("Defendant; evidence of mental condition admissible.") did not pass the Virginia Legislature, by a recorded vote of 82 to 54. Last action: March 14, 2026.
Virginia file HB1411, before the Virginia Legislature. Did not pass as of 2026-03-14.
Official summary
Evidence of defendant's mental condition admissible. Provides that evidence of the defendant's mental condition at the time of the alleged offense, including lay testimony, may be admitted and considered if such evidence (i) has any tendency to show the defendant did or did not have a mental state that is an element of the offense or an affirmative defense and (ii) is otherwise admissible pursuant to the general rules of evidence. The bill also provides such evidence offered by the defendant that shows he had a mental condition at the time of or near any act related to the offense, or a defense to or for such offense, is admissible as it has a tendency to show the defendant did not have the required mental state. The current standard requires that such evidence tend to show the defendant did not have the intent required for the offense charged. The bill also provides that notwithstanding any other provision of law or rule of evidence, any statement made by the accused to an expert during an examination to allow such expert to form an opinion on whether or not the accused had a mental condition at the time of or near any act related to the offense, or a defense to or for such offens
How they voted
Yes (82)
- Kim Adams (D, HD 82)
- Lashrecse Aird (D, SD 13)
- Jessica Anderson (D, HD 71)
- Bonita Anthony (D, HD 92)
- Alex Askew (D, HD 95)
- Lamont Bagby (D, SD 14)
- Elizabeth Bennett-Parker (D, SD 39)
- Destiny LeVere Bolling (D, HD 80)
- Jennifer Boysko (D, SD 38)
- Gretchen Bulova (D, HD 11)
- Katrina Callsen (D, HD 54)
- Kacey Carnegie (D, HD 89)
- Betsy Carr (D, HD 78)
- Stacey Carroll (D, HD 64)
- Laura Jane Cohen (D, HD 15)
- Josh Cole (D, HD 65)
- Nicole Cole (D, HD 66)
- Rae Cousins (D, HD 79)
- Creigh Deeds (D, SD 11)
- Karrie Delaney (D, HD 9)
- Lindsey Dougherty (D, HD 75)
- Mark Downey (D, HD 69)
- Barbara Favola (D, SD 40)
- Michael Feggans (D, HD 97)
- Kelly Fowler (D, HD 96)
- Jennifer Carroll Foy (D, SD 33)
- Lily Franklin (D, HD 41)
- Margaret Franklin (D, HD 23)
- Debra Gardner (D, HD 76)
- Jackie Glass (D, HD 93)
- Angelia Graves (D, SD 21)
- Liz Guzmán (D, HD 22)
- Cliff Hayes (D, HD 91)
- Dan Helmer (D, HD 10)
- J.R. Henson (D, HD 19)
- Phil Hernandez (D, HD 94)
- Charniele Herring (D, HD 4)
- Patrick Hope (D, HD 1)
- Mike Jones (D, SD 15)
- Karen Keys-Gamarra (D, HD 7)
- Paul Krizek (D, HD 16)
- Amy Laufer (D, HD 55)
- Mamie Locke (D, SD 23)
- Alfonso Lopez (D, HD 3)
- Louise Lucas (D, SD 18)
- Michelle Maldonado (D)
- Dave Marsden (D, SD 35)
- Marty Martinez (D, HD 29)
- Adele McClure (D, HD 2)
- Garrett McGuire (D, HD 17)
- Jeremy McPike (D, SD 29)
- Delores McQuinn (D, HD 81)
- Leslie Mehta (D, HD 73)
- May Nivar (D, HD 57)
- Stella Pekarsky (D, SD 36)
- Russet Perry (D, SD 31)
- Cia Price (D, HD 85)
- Sam Rasoul (D, HD 38)
- Atoosa Reaser (D, HD 27)
- David Reid (D, HD 28)
- Danica Roem (D, SD 30)
- Aaron Rouse (D, SD 22)
- Saddam Salim (D, SD 37)
- Charlie Schmidt (D, HD 77)
- Don Scott (D, HD 88)
- Holly Seibold (D, HD 12)
- Briana Sewell (D, HD 25)
- Irene Shin (D, HD 8)
- Marcus Simon (D, HD 13)
- Shelly Simonds (D, HD 70)
- J.J. Singh (D, HD 26)
- Kannan Srinivasan (D, SD 32)
- Rip Sullivan (D, HD 6)
- Scott Surovell (D, SD 34)
- Josh Thomas (D, HD 21)
- Virgil Thornton (D, HD 86)
- Luke Torian (D, HD 24)
- Kathy Tran (D, HD 18)
- Schuyler VanValkenburg (D, SD 16)
- Jeion Ward (D, HD 87)
- Vivian Watts (D, HD 14)
- Rod Willett (D, HD 58)
No (54)
- Terry Austin (R, HD 37)
- Jason Ballard (R, HD 42)
- Rob Bloxom (R, HD 100)
- Mike Cherry (R, HD 74)
- Luther Cifers (R, SD 10)
- Mitchell Cornett (R, HD 46)
- Christie Craig (R, SD 19)
- Will Davis (R, HD 39)
- Bill DeSteph (R, SD 20)
- Danny Diggs (R, SD 24)
- Tara Durant (R, SD 27)
- Buddy Fowler (R, HD 59)
- Timmy French (R, SD 1)
- Tom Garrett (R, HD 56)
- Tim Griffin (R, HD 53)
- Travis Hackworth (R, SD 5)
- Karen Hamilton (R, HD 62)
- Chris Head (R, SD 3)
- Keith Hodges (R, HD 68)
- Emily Jordan (R, SD 17)
- Hillary Pugh Kent (R, HD 67)
- Terry Kilgore (R, HD 45)
- Jay Leftwich (R, HD 90)
- Ryan McDougle (R, SD 26)
- Ellen McLaughlin (R, HD 36)
- Joe McNamara (R, HD 40)
- Will Morefield (R, HD 43)
- Tammy Mulchi (R, SD 9)
- Israel O'Quinn (R, HD 44)
- Delores Oates (R, HD 31)
- Mark Obenshain (R, SD 2)
- Mark Peake (R, SD 8)
- Justin Pence (R, HD 33)
- Eric Phillips (R, HD 48)
- Todd Pillion (R, SD 6)
- Bryce Reeves (R, SD 28)
- Chris Runion (R, HD 35)
- Phil Scott (R, HD 63)
- Bill Stanley (R, SD 7)
- Richard Stuart (R, SD 25)
- Glen Sturtevant (R, SD 12)
- David Suetterlein (R, SD 4)
- Anne Ferrell Tata (R, HD 99)
- Otto Wachsmann (R, HD 83)
- Wendell Walker (R, HD 52)
- Lee Ware (R, HD 72)
- Mike Webert (R, HD 61)
- Madison Whittle (R, HD 49)
- Bill Wiley (R, HD 32)
- Wren Williams (R, HD 47)
- Tony Wilt (R, HD 34)
- Tommy Wright (R, HD 50)
- Scott Wyatt (R, HD 60)
- Eric Zehr (R, HD 51)
Did not vote / other (2)
Read the official record for HB1411
See everything up for a vote · This week in Virginia · See what we have filed with the clerk