Restrict ESG factors in retirement plan investments

Bill hr5339-118 ("Restrict ESG factors in retirement plan investments") is before Congress and has not been decided.

Congress file hr5339-118, before Congress. No action in 790 days as of 2024-09-18.

What it does

Plan managers must focus solely on profit and risk metrics Fiduciaries managing your 401(k) or pension plan are now required to base investment choices only on pecuniary factors—expected financial returns and risk—and cannot consider environmental, social, or governance (ESG) criteria unless they cannot distinguish between investment options on financial grounds alone.

The bigger picture

Investment funds may shift away from ESG-screened portfolios Asset managers and fund providers may restructure or phase out ESG-focused investment products that plan sponsors previously offered, reducing available options that align with non-financial values and potentially consolidating industry offerings around traditional financial-only strategies.

What to watch

Debate persists on whether ESG factors predict financial performance Economic research remains divided on whether ESG metrics correlate with long-term returns; some investors and analysts argue restricting their consideration may exclude information relevant to prudent risk assessment, while the law's carve-outs for participant-directed plans and tie-breaking scenarios create ambiguity in implementation.

Official summary

Roll back ESG To Increase Retirement Earnings Act or the RETIRE Act This bill generally requires fiduciaries of employer-sponsored retirement plans to make investment decisions based only on pecuniary factors (i.e., factors that a fiduciary prudently determines are expected to have a material effect on the risk or return of an investment based on appropriate investment horizons consistent with the plan's policies and objectives). The bill allows nonpecuniary factors to be considered in certain situations, such as when selecting investment options for certain participant-directed retirement plans or if the fiduciary is unable to distinguish between investment alternatives on the basis of pecuniary factors alone.

How they voted

Yes (184)

No (180)

Did not vote / other (5)

Read the official record for hr5339-118

See everything up for a vote · This week in Congress · See what we have filed with the clerk