Removes DC judicial nomination commission, empowers President

Bill hr5125-119 ("Removes DC judicial nomination commission, empowers President") is before Congress and has not been decided.

Congress file hr5125-119, before Congress. No action in 426 days as of 2025-09-17.

What it does

DC judge appointments bypass local commission process DC Superior Court and Court of Appeals judges will now be nominated directly by the President rather than selected from a commission-vetted list, removing local input from the nomination pipeline.

The bigger picture

Shifts judicial selection control to federal executive The change concentrates DC judicial appointment authority entirely with the President, eliminating a semi-independent vetting body and reducing the role of DC's local government in selecting judges for its courts.

What to watch

Senate confirmation still required; judicial independence effects unclear While the President gains direct nomination power, Senate confirmation remains mandatory, but judicial impartiality advocates warn that removing the commission's professional vetting layer may reduce the perceived independence of DC's bench.

Official summary

District of Columbia Judicial Nominations Reform ActThis bill terminates the District of Columbia (DC) Judicial Nomination Commission. Currently, the commission recommends to the President nominees for judges for DC's Superior Court and Court of Appeals, who must then be confirmed by the Senate. The commission also appoints the chief judges for these courts. The bill terminates the commission's involvement in nominations and requires the President to appoint the chief judges.

How they voted

Yes (216)

No (210)

Did not vote / other (3)

Read the official record for hr5125-119

See everything up for a vote · This week in Congress · See what we have filed with the clerk