Bans age and disability factors in Medicare coverage decisions
Bill hr485-118 ("Bans age and disability factors in Medicare coverage decisions") did not pass Congress, by a recorded vote of 177 to 178. Last action: February 7, 2024.
Congress file hr485-118, before Congress. Did not pass as of 2024-02-07.
What it does
Disabled and elderly patients get equal treatment consideration Medicare, Medicaid, and other federal programs must now evaluate treatments based on medical effectiveness without discounting value because you are older, disabled, or terminally ill.
The bigger picture
Drug approval and pricing calculations shift across federal programs Federal health agencies will need to revise how they assess cost-effectiveness for new drugs and treatments, potentially affecting which therapies qualify for federal coverage and reimbursement across Medicare, Medicaid, and VA systems.
What to watch
Prevention funding cut; bill stalls in Senate Finance Committee The bill cuts Prevention and Public Health Fund spending by an unspecified amount through 2029, and has not advanced beyond the Senate Finance Committee since February 2024, making passage uncertain.
Official summary
Protecting Health Care for All Patients Act of 2023 This bill prohibits all federal health care programs, including the Federal Employees Health Benefits Program, and federally funded state health care programs (e.g., Medicaid) from using prices that are based on quality-adjusted life years (i.e., measures that discount the value of a life based on disability, age, or terminal illness) to determine relevant thresholds for coverage, reimbursements, or incentive programs. The Government Accountability Office must annually report on how the use of quality-adjusted life years negatively affects individuals with intellectual and developmental disabilities. The bill also reduces funding for the Prevention and Public Health Fund for FY2024-FY2029.
How they voted
Yes (177)
- Robert B. Aderholt (R, District 4)
- Mark Alford (R, District 4)
- Rick W. Allen (R, District 12)
- Mark E. Amodei (R, District 2)
- Jodey C. Arrington (R, District 19)
- Brian Babin (R, District 36)
- Don Bacon (R, District 2)
- James R. Baird (R, District 4)
- Troy Balderson (R, District 12)
- Jim Banks (R)
- Andy Barr (R, District 6)
- Aaron Bean (R, District 4)
- Cliff Bentz (R, District 2)
- Jack Bergman (R, District 1)
- Stephanie I. Bice (R, District 5)
- Andy Biggs (R, District 5)
- Gus M. Bilirakis (R, District 12)
- Lauren Boebert (R, District 4)
- Mike Bost (R, District 12)
- Josh Brecheen (R, District 2)
- Vern Buchanan (R, District 16)
- Tim Burchett (R, District 2)
- Eric Burlison (R, District 7)
- Ken Calvert (R, District 41)
- Kat Cammack (R, District 3)
- Mike Carey (R, District 15)
- Earl L. "Buddy" Carter (R, District 1)
- Juan Ciscomani (R, District 6)
- Ben Cline (R, District 6)
- Michael Cloud (R, District 27)
- Andrew S. Clyde (R, District 9)
- Tom Cole (R, District 4)
- Mike Collins (R, District 10)
- James Comer (R, District 1)
- Elijah Crane (R, District 2)
- Eric A. "Rick" Crawford (R, District 1)
- Dan Crenshaw (R, District 2)
- John R. Curtis (R)
- Warren Davidson (R, District 8)
- Monica De La Cruz (R, District 15)
- Scott DesJarlais (R, District 4)
- Mario Diaz-Balart (R, District 26)
- Byron Donalds (R, District 19)
- Neal P. Dunn (R, District 2)
- Chuck Edwards (R, District 11)
- Jake Ellzey (R, District 6)
- Tom Emmer (R, District 6)
- Ron Estes (R, District 4)
- Mike Ezell (R, District 4)
- Pat Fallon (R, District 4)
- Randy Feenstra (R, District 4)
- Brad Finstad (R, District 1)
- Michelle Fischbach (R, District 7)
- Scott Fitzgerald (R, District 5)
- Brian K. Fitzpatrick (R, District 1)
- Charles J. "Chuck" Fleischmann (R, District 3)
- Mike Flood (R, District 1)
- Virginia Foxx (R, District 5)
- Scott Franklin (R, District 18)
- Russell Fry (R, District 7)
- Russ Fulcher (R, District 1)
- Andrew R. Garbarino (R, District 2)
- Carlos A. Gimenez (R, District 28)
- Tony Gonzales (R)
- Lance Gooden (R, District 5)
- Paul A. Gosar (R, District 9)
- Sam Graves (R, District 6)
- H. Morgan Griffith (R, District 9)
- Glenn Grothman (R, District 6)
- Michael Guest (R, District 3)
- Brett Guthrie (R, District 2)
- Harriet M. Hageman (R)
- Diana Harshbarger (R, District 1)
- Kevin Hern (R, District 1)
- Clay Higgins (R, District 3)
- J. French Hill (R, District 2)
- Ashley Hinson (R, District 2)
- Erin Houchin (R, District 9)
- Richard Hudson (R, District 9)
- Bill Huizenga (R, District 4)
- Wesley Hunt (R, District 38)
- Darrell Issa (R, District 48)
- Ronny Jackson (R, District 13)
- John James (R, District 10)
- Dusty Johnson (R)
- Jim Jordan (R, District 4)
- David P. Joyce (R, District 14)
- John Joyce (R, District 13)
- Thomas H. Kean (R, District 7)
- Mike Kelly (R, District 16)
- Trent Kelly (R, District 1)
- Jennifer A. Kiggans (R, District 2)
- Kevin Kiley (District 3)
- David Kustoff (R, District 8)
- Darin LaHood (R, District 16)
- Nick LaLota (R, District 1)
- Robert E. Latta (R, District 5)
- Michael Lawler (R, District 17)
- Laurel M. Lee (R, District 15)
- Julia Letlow (R, District 5)
- Barry Loudermilk (R, District 11)
- Frank D. Lucas (R, District 3)
- Morgan Luttrell (R, District 8)
- Nancy Mace (R, District 1)
- Nicole Malliotakis (R, District 11)
- Celeste Maloy (R, District 2)
- Tracey Mann (R, District 1)
- Thomas Massie (R, District 4)
- Brian J. Mast (R, District 21)
- Michael T. McCaul (R, District 10)
- Lisa C. McClain (R, District 9)
- Tom McClintock (R, District 5)
- Richard McCormick (R, District 7)
- Daniel Meuser (R, District 9)
- Mariannette Miller-Meeks (R, District 1)
- Carol D. Miller (R, District 1)
- Mary E. Miller (R, District 15)
- Max L. Miller (R, District 7)
- Cory Mills (R, District 7)
- John R. Moolenaar (R, District 2)
- Barry Moore (R, District 1)
- Blake D. Moore (R, District 1)
- Nathaniel Moran (R, District 1)
- Gregory F. Murphy (R, District 3)
- Troy E. Nehls (R, District 22)
- Dan Newhouse (R, District 4)
- Ralph Norman (R, District 5)
- Zachary Nunn (R, District 3)
- Jay Obernolte (R, District 23)
- Andrew Ogles (R, District 5)
- Burgess Owens (R, District 4)
- Gary J. Palmer (R, District 6)
- Scott Perry (R, District 10)
- August Pfluger (R, District 11)
- Guy Reschenthaler (R, District 14)
- Harold Rogers (R, District 5)
- Mike D. Rogers (R, District 3)
- John W. Rose (R, District 6)
- David Rouzer (R, District 7)
- Chip Roy (R, District 21)
- John H. Rutherford (R, District 5)
- Maria Elvira Salazar (R, District 27)
- David Schweikert (R, District 1)
- Austin Scott (R, District 8)
- Keith Self (R, District 3)
- Pete Sessions (R, District 17)
- Michael K. Simpson (R, District 2)
- Adrian Smith (R, District 3)
- Christopher H. Smith (R, District 4)
- Jason Smith (R, District 8)
- Lloyd Smucker (R, District 11)
- Victoria Spartz (R, District 5)
- Pete Stauber (R, District 8)
- Elise M. Stefanik (R, District 21)
- Bryan Steil (R, District 1)
- W. Gregory Steube (R, District 17)
- Dale W. Strong (R, District 5)
- Claudia Tenney (R, District 24)
- Glenn Thompson (R, District 15)
- Thomas P. Tiffany (R, District 7)
- William R. Timmons (R, District 4)
- Michael R. Turner (R, District 10)
- David G. Valadao (R, District 22)
- Jefferson Van Drew (R, District 2)
- Beth Van Duyne (R, District 24)
- Derrick Van Orden (R, District 3)
- Ann Wagner (R, District 2)
- Tim Walberg (R, District 5)
- Randy K. Sr. Weber (R, District 14)
- Daniel Webster (R, District 11)
- Bruce Westerman (R, District 4)
- Roger Williams (R, District 25)
- Joe Wilson (R, District 2)
- Robert J. Wittman (R, District 1)
- Steve Womack (R, District 3)
- Rudy Yakym (R, District 2)
- Ryan K. Zinke (R, District 1)
No (178)
- Alma S. Adams (D, District 12)
- Pete Aguilar (D, District 33)
- Gabe Amo (D, District 1)
- Jake Auchincloss (D, District 4)
- Becca Balint (D)
- Nanette Diaz Barragán (D, District 44)
- Joyce Beatty (D, District 3)
- Ami Bera (D, District 6)
- Donald S. Beyer (D, District 8)
- Sanford D. Bishop (D, District 2)
- Lisa Blunt Rochester (D)
- Suzanne Bonamici (D, District 1)
- Brendan F. Boyle (D, District 2)
- Shontel M. Brown (D, District 11)
- Julia Brownley (D, District 26)
- Nikki Budzinski (D, District 13)
- Salud O. Carbajal (D, District 24)
- André Carson (D, District 7)
- Troy A. Carter (D, District 2)
- Greg Casar (D, District 35)
- Ed Case (D, District 1)
- Sean Casten (D, District 6)
- Kathy Castor (D, District 14)
- Joaquin Castro (D, District 20)
- Sheila Cherfilus-McCormick (D)
- Judy Chu (D, District 28)
- Katherine M. Clark (D, District 5)
- Yvette D. Clarke (D, District 9)
- Emanuel Cleaver (D, District 5)
- James E. Clyburn (D, District 6)
- Steve Cohen (D, District 9)
- J. Luis Correa (D, District 46)
- Jim Costa (D, District 21)
- Joe Courtney (D, District 2)
- Angie Craig (D, District 2)
- Jasmine Crockett (D, District 30)
- Jason Crow (D, District 6)
- Henry Cuellar (D, District 28)
- Sharice Davids (D, District 3)
- Danny K. Davis (D, District 7)
- Donald G. Davis (D, District 1)
- Madeleine Dean (D, District 4)
- Diana DeGette (D, District 1)
- Rosa L. DeLauro (D, District 3)
- Suzan K. DelBene (D, District 1)
- Christopher R. Deluzio (D, District 17)
- Mark DeSaulnier (D, District 10)
- Debbie Dingell (D, District 6)
- Lloyd Doggett (D, District 37)
- Veronica Escobar (D, District 16)
- Adriano Espaillat (D, District 13)
- Dwight Evans (D, District 3)
- Lizzie Fletcher (D, District 7)
- Bill Foster (D, District 11)
- Valerie P. Foushee (D, District 4)
- Lois Frankel (D, District 22)
- Maxwell Frost (D, District 10)
- Ruben Gallego (D)
- John Garamendi (D, District 8)
- Jesús G. "Chuy" García (D, District 4)
- Robert Garcia (D, District 42)
- Sylvia R. Garcia (D, District 29)
- Jared F. Golden (D, District 2)
- Daniel S. Goldman (D, District 10)
- Jimmy Gomez (D, District 34)
- Vicente Gonzalez (D, District 34)
- Josh Gottheimer (D, District 5)
- Josh Harder (D, District 9)
- Jahana Hayes (D, District 5)
- James A. Himes (D, District 4)
- Steven Horsford (D, District 4)
- Chrissy Houlahan (D, District 6)
- Steny H. Hoyer (D, District 5)
- Val T. Hoyle (D, District 4)
- Jared Huffman (D, District 2)
- Glenn Ivey (D, District 4)
- Jonathan L. Jackson (D, District 1)
- Sara Jacobs (D, District 51)
- Pramila Jayapal (D, District 7)
- Hakeem S. Jeffries (D, District 8)
- Henry C. "Hank" Johnson (D, District 4)
- Sydney Kamlager-Dove (D, District 37)
- Marcy Kaptur (D, District 9)
- William R. Keating (D, District 9)
- Robin L. Kelly (D, District 2)
- Ro Khanna (D, District 17)
- Raja Krishnamoorthi (D, District 8)
- Greg Landsman (D, District 1)
- Rick Larsen (D, District 2)
- Summer L. Lee (D, District 12)
- Susie Lee (D, District 3)
- Teresa Leger Fernandez (D, District 3)
- Mike Levin (D, District 49)
- Ted Lieu (D, District 36)
- Zoe Lofgren (D, District 18)
- Stephen F. Lynch (D, District 8)
- Seth Magaziner (D, District 2)
- Doris O. Matsui (D, District 7)
- Lucy McBath (D, District 6)
- Jennifer L. McClellan (D, District 4)
- Betty McCollum (D, District 4)
- Morgan McGarvey (D, District 3)
- James P. McGovern (D, District 2)
- Gregory W. Meeks (D, District 5)
- Robert Menendez (D, District 8)
- Grace Meng (D, District 6)
- Kweisi Mfume (D, District 7)
- Gwen Moore (D, District 4)
- Joseph D. Morelle (D, District 25)
- Jared Moskowitz (D, District 23)
- Seth Moulton (D, District 6)
- Frank J. Mrvan (D, District 1)
- Kevin Mullin (D, District 15)
- Jerrold Nadler (D, District 12)
- Richard E. Neal (D, District 1)
- Joe Neguse (D, District 2)
- Donald Norcross (D, District 1)
- Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D, District 14)
- Ilhan Omar (D, District 5)
- Frank Pallone (D, District 6)
- Jimmy Panetta (D, District 19)
- Chris Pappas (D, District 1)
- Nancy Pelosi (D, District 11)
- Marie Gluesenkamp Perez (D, District 3)
- Scott H. Peters (D, District 50)
- Brittany Pettersen (D, District 7)
- Chellie Pingree (D, District 1)
- Mark Pocan (D, District 2)
- Ayanna Pressley (D, District 7)
- Mike Quigley (D, District 5)
- Delia C. Ramirez (D, District 3)
- Jamie Raskin (D, District 8)
- Deborah K. Ross (D, District 2)
- Raul Ruiz (D, District 25)
- Patrick Ryan (D, District 18)
- Andrea Salinas (D, District 6)
- Linda T. Sánchez (D, District 38)
- Mary Gay Scanlon (D, District 5)
- Janice D. Schakowsky (D, District 9)
- Adam B. Schiff (D)
- Bradley Scott Schneider (D, District 10)
- Hillary J. Scholten (D, District 3)
- Kim Schrier (D, District 8)
- David Scott (D)
- Robert C. "Bobby" Scott (D, District 3)
- Terri A. Sewell (D, District 7)
- Brad Sherman (D, District 32)
- Elissa Slotkin (D)
- Adam Smith (D, District 9)
- Eric Sorensen (D, District 17)
- Darren Soto (D, District 9)
- Melanie A. Stansbury (D, District 1)
- Greg Stanton (D, District 4)
- Haley M. Stevens (D, District 11)
- Marilyn Strickland (D, District 10)
- Eric Swalwell (D)
- Emilia Strong Sykes (D, District 13)
- Mark Takano (D, District 39)
- Shri Thanedar (D, District 13)
- Bennie G. Thompson (D, District 2)
- Mike Thompson (D, District 4)
- Dina Titus (D, District 1)
- Rashida Tlaib (D, District 12)
- Jill N. Tokuda (D, District 2)
- Paul Tonko (D, District 20)
- Norma J. Torres (D, District 35)
- Ritchie Torres (D, District 15)
- Lori Trahan (D, District 3)
- Lauren Underwood (D, District 14)
- Juan Vargas (D, District 52)
- Gabe Vasquez (D, District 2)
- Marc A. Veasey (D, District 33)
- Nydia M. Velázquez (D, District 7)
- Debbie Wasserman Schultz (D, District 25)
- Maxine Waters (D, District 43)
- Bonnie Watson Coleman (D, District 12)
- Nikema Williams (D, District 5)
- Frederica S. Wilson (D, District 24)
Did not vote / other (9)
Read the official record for hr485-118
See everything up for a vote · This week in Congress · See what we have filed with the clerk