Courts must second-guess federal agency interpretations

Bill hr288-118 ("Courts must second-guess federal agency interpretations") is before Congress and has not been decided.

Congress file hr288-118, before Congress. No action in 1251 days as of 2023-06-15.

What it does

You gain stronger grounds to sue federal agencies If you challenge an agency rule or guidance in court, judges will now review the agency's legal interpretation independently rather than deferring to it, making it easier to win cases against EPA, FDA, DOL, and other regulators.

The bigger picture

Regulatory stability and speed may decline significantly Agencies will face more court defeats on interpretation questions, creating legal uncertainty that may slow rule-making, force costly rewrites, and encourage more litigation—shifting power from executive branch to federal courts.

What to watch

Public health and safety rules face new legal jeopardy Environmental, health, and worker safety standards that depend on agency expertise and interpretation could be struck down by judges with no background in those fields, potentially weakening protections before alternatives are established.

Official summary

Separation of Powers Restoration Act of 2023 or SOPRA This bill modifies the scope of judicial review of agency actions to authorize courts reviewing agency actions to decide de novo (i.e., without giving deference to the agency's interpretation) all relevant questions of law, including the interpretation of (1) constitutional and statutory provisions, (2) rules made by agencies, (3) interpretative rules, (4) general statements of policy, and (5) all other agency guidance documents. No law may exempt a civil action from the standard of review required by this bill except by specific reference to such provision.

How they voted

Yes (184)

No (178)

Did not vote / other (1)

Read the official record for hr288-118

See everything up for a vote · This week in Congress · See what we have filed with the clerk