Requires new jury deliberations when alternate juror joins

File S09770 ("Requires new jury deliberations when alternate juror joins") is before the New York Legislature and has not been decided. Latest step (April 27, 2026): Senate Floor Calendar.

New York file S09770, before the New York Legislature. Still to be decided as of 2026-04-27.

What it does

Jury trials may take longer when alternate jurors are seated If a juror becomes unable to serve after deliberations begin, the replacement juror requires the entire jury to restart deliberations on all unresolved issues, extending trial timelines.

The bigger picture

Court system faces longer case backlogs and increased juror service demands Longer deliberation cycles when alternates are substituted will increase court scheduling pressure and may extend the total time jurors must remain available for duty.

What to watch

Verdicts already reached before substitution remain valid and final The bill exempts issues on which a verdict was already rendered, so only unresolved questions require re-deliberation, limiting the scope of delay in some cases.

Official summary

Provides that after an alternate juror has been substituted, the jury shall deliberate anew on all issues submitted to the jury at the outset of deliberations; exempts issues for which a verdict was already rendered.

How they voted

Yes (15)

Read the official record for S09770

See everything up for a vote · This week in New York · See what we have filed with the clerk