Expands judge eligibility for youth courts
The New York Legislature approved file S08196 ("Expands judge eligibility for youth courts"), by a recorded vote of 202 to 0. Last action: November 21, 2025.
New York file S08196, before the New York Legislature. Passed as of 2025-11-21.
What it does
Broader pool of judges handles youth cases Young people appearing before designated youth parts may now be heard by judges who were previously ineligible under prior qualification rules, potentially affecting case assignment timelines and judicial handling.
The bigger picture
Judicial workload distribution shifts across courts Expanding the eligible judge pool may reduce caseload concentration in youth courts and allow more flexible staffing decisions, but could also dilute specialization if newly eligible judges lack dedicated youth-court training.
What to watch
Risk of reduced judicial expertise in youth matters Judges newly eligible under the expanded criteria may lack experience in juvenile law, social-service coordination, and the rehabilitative (rather than purely punitive) framework that youth parts are designed to apply.
How they voted
Yes (202)
- George Alvarez (D, HD 78)
- Stacey Pheffer Amato (D, HD 23)
- Khaleel M. Anderson (D, HD 31)
- Joe Angelino (R, HD 121)
- Jr. Anil Beephan (R, HD 105)
- Jake Ashby (R, SD 43)
- Andrea K. Bailey (R, HD 133)
- Jamaal Bailey (D, SD 36)
- William A. Barclay (R, HD 120)
- Didi Barrett (D, HD 106)
- April Baskin (D, SD 63)
- Scott Bendett (R, HD 107)
- Michael Benedetto (D, HD 82)
- Ken Blankenbush (R, HD 117)
- Jake Blumencranz (R, HD 15)
- Paul A. Bologna (R, HD 144)
- Alex Bores (D, HD 73)
- George Borrello (R, SD 57)
- Karl Brabenec (R, HD 98)
- Edward C. Braunstein (D, HD 26)
- Jabari Brisport (D, SD 25)
- Harry B. Bronson (D, HD 138)
- Alec Brook-Krasny (R, HD 46)
- Samra Brouk (D, SD 55)
- Ari Brown (R, HD 20)
- Keith P. Brown (R, HD 12)
- Chris Burdick (D, HD 93)
- Patrick Burke (D, HD 142)
- Noah Burroughs (D, HD 18)
- Marianne Buttenschon (D, HD 119)
- Siela Bynoe (D, SD 6)
- Patricia Canzoneri-Fitzpatrick (R, SD 9)
- Patrick J. Carroll (D, HD 96)
- Robert C. Carroll (D, HD 44)
- Stephen T. Chan (R, SD 17)
- Monique Chandler-Waterman (D, HD 58)
- Lester Chang (R, HD 49)
- Patrick J. Chludzinski (R, HD 143)
- Sarah Clark (D, HD 136)
- Cordell Cleare (D, SD 30)
- William Colton (D, HD 47)
- Leroy Comrie (D, SD 14)
- William Conrad (D, HD 140)
- Vivian E. Cook (D, HD 32)
- Jeremy Cooney (D, SD 56)
- Catalina Cruz (D, HD 39)
- Brian Cunningham (D, HD 43)
- Landon C. Dais (D, HD 77)
- Maritza Davila (D, HD 53)
- Joe DeStefano (R, HD 3)
- Erik M. Dilan (D, HD 54)
- Jeffrey Dinowitz (D, HD 81)
- David DiPietro (R, HD 147)
- Michael Durso (R, HD 9)
- Chris Eachus (D, HD 99)
- Simcha Eichenstein (D, HD 48)
- Harvey Epstein (D)
- Patricia Fahy (D, SD 46)
- Charles D. Fall (D, HD 61)
- Nathalia Fernandez (D, SD 34)
- Michael J. Fitzpatrick (R, HD 8)
- Phara Souffrant Forrest (D, HD 57)
- Christopher S. Friend (R, HD 124)
- Emily Gallagher (D, HD 50)
- Jeff Gallahan (R, HD 131)
- Patrick M. Gallivan (R, SD 60)
- Jarett Gandolfo (R, HD 7)
- Michael Gianaris (D, SD 12)
- Edward Gibbs (D, HD 68)
- Jodi Giglio (R, HD 2)
- Deborah J. Glick (D, HD 66)
- Kristen Gonzalez (D, SD 59)
- Jessica González-Rojas (D, HD 34)
- Andrew Gounardes (D, SD 26)
- Scott Gray (R, HD 116)
- Judy Griffin (D, HD 21)
- Joseph A. Griffo (R, SD 53)
- Pete Harckham (D, SD 40)
- Stephen Hawley (R, HD 139)
- Carl E. Heastie (D, HD 83)
- Pamela Helming (R, SD 54)
- Rodneyse Bichotte Hermelyn (D, HD 42)
- Andrew Hevesi (D, HD 28)
- Michelle Hinchey (D, SD 41)
- Larinda C. Hooks (D, HD 35)
- Brad Hoylman-Sigal (D, SD 47)
- Pamela J. Hunter (D, HD 128)
- Alicia Hyndman (D, HD 29)
- John T. McDonald III (D, HD 108)
- Chantel Jackson (D, HD 79)
- Robert Jackson (D, SD 31)
- Jonathan G. Jacobson (D, HD 104)
- Josh Jensen (R, HD 134)
- Jr. John Zaccaro (D, HD 80)
- D. Billy Jones (D)
- James Sanders Jr. (D, SD 10)
- Rebecca Kassay (D, HD 4)
- Brian Kavanagh (D, SD 27)
- Paula Elaine Kay (HD 100)
- Dr. Anna R. Kelles (D, HD 125)
- Ron Kim (D, HD 40)
- Liz Krueger (D, SD 28)
- Andrew J. Lanza (R, SD 24)
- Micah C. Lasher (D, HD 69)
- Charles D. Lavine (D, HD 13)
- Grace Lee (D, HD 65)
- John Lemondes (R, HD 126)
- Dana Levenberg (D, HD 95)
- John Liu (D, SD 16)
- Nikki Lucas (D, HD 60)
- Jen Lunsford (D, HD 135)
- Donna A. Lupardo (D, HD 123)
- William B. Magnarelli (D, HD 129)
- Brian Maher (R, HD 101)
- Brian Manktelow (R, HD 130)
- Monica Martinez (D, SD 4)
- Jack M. Martins (R, SD 7)
- Mario Mattera (R, SD 2)
- Rachel May (D, SD 48)
- Shelley Mayer (D, SD 37)
- David G. McDonough (R, HD 14)
- Karen McMahon (D, HD 146)
- Demond Meeks (D, HD 137)
- John K. Mikulin (R, HD 17)
- Brian D. Miller (R, HD 122)
- Marcela Mitaynes (D, HD 51)
- Andrew M. Molitor (R, HD 150)
- Angelo J. Morinello (R, HD 145)
- Daniel J. Norber (R, HD 16)
- Michael Novakhov (R, HD 45)
- Thomas F. O'Mara (R, SD 58)
- Kwani B. O'Pharrow (D, HD 11)
- Peter Oberacker (R, SD 51)
- Robert Ortt (R, SD 62)
- Steven Otis (D, HD 91)
- Philip A. Palmesano (R, HD 132)
- Anthony H. Palumbo (R, SD 1)
- Kevin S. Parker (D, SD 21)
- Amy Paulin (D, HD 88)
- Crystal D. Peoples-Stokes (D, HD 141)
- Roxanne J. Persaud (D, SD 19)
- Sam Pirozzolo (R, HD 63)
- J. Gary Pretlow (D, HD 89)
- Edward P. Ra (R, HD 19)
- Steven Raga (D, HD 30)
- Phil Ramos (D, HD 6)
- Michael Reilly (R, HD 62)
- Karines Reyes (D, HD 87)
- Steve Rhoads (R, SD 5)
- Gustavo Rivera (D, SD 33)
- Jonathan Rivera (D, HD 149)
- Robert Rolison (R, SD 39)
- Gabriella A. Romero (D, HD 109)
- Linda B. Rosenthal (D, HD 67)
- Christopher Ryan (D, SD 50)
- Sean Ryan (D, SD 61)
- Julia Salazar (D, SD 18)
- Angelo Santabarbara (D, HD 111)
- Manny De Los Santos (D, HD 72)
- Nader J. Sayegh (D, HD 90)
- Jessica Scarcella-Spanton (D, SD 23)
- Tommy John Schiavoni (D, HD 1)
- Rebecca A. Seawright (D, HD 76)
- Joe Sempolinski (R, HD 148)
- Luis R. Sepúlveda (D, SD 32)
- José M. Serrano (D, SD 29)
- MaryJane Shimsky (D, HD 92)
- Sarahana Shrestha (D, HD 103)
- Jo Anne Simon (D, HD 52)
- Tony Simone (D, HD 75)
- Matthew Simpson (R, HD 114)
- James Skoufis (D, SD 42)
- Matt Slater (R, HD 94)
- Doug Smith (R, HD 5)
- Robert Smullen (R, HD 118)
- Michaelle C. Solages (D, HD 22)
- Toby Ann Stavisky (D, SD 11)
- Dan Stec (R, SD 45)
- Phil Steck (D, HD 110)
- Steve Stern (D, HD 10)
- Andrea Stewart-Cousins (D, SD 35)
- Al Stirpe (D, HD 127)
- Chris Tague (R, HD 102)
- Yudelka Tapia (D, HD 86)
- Al Taylor (D, HD 71)
- James Tedisco (R, SD 44)
- Emérita Torres (D, HD 85)
- Claire Valdez (D, HD 37)
- Clyde Vanel (D, HD 33)
- Mark Walczyk (R, SD 49)
- Latrice M. Walker (HD 55)
- Mary Beth Walsh (R, HD 112)
- Lea Webb (D, SD 52)
- William Weber (R, SD 38)
- Alexis Weik (R, SD 8)
- David I. Weprin (D, HD 24)
- Aron Wieder (D, HD 97)
- Jaime R. Williams (D, HD 59)
- Carrie Woerner (D, HD 113)
- Jordan J.G. Wright (D, HD 70)
- Kalman Yeger (D, HD 41)
- Stefani Zinerman (D, HD 56)
Did not vote / other (11)
- Sam Berger (D, HD 27): Present
- Joseph P. Addabbo Jr. (D, SD 15): Present
- Zohran Kwame Mamdani (D): Present
- Dean Murray (R, SD 3): Present
- Zellnor Myrie (D, SD 20): Present
- Jenifer Rajkumar (D, HD 38): Present
- Jessica Ramos (D, SD 13): Present
- Nily Rozic (D, HD 25): Present
- Amanda Septimo (D, HD 84): Present
- Sam Sutton (D, SD 22): Present
- Michael Tannousis (R, HD 64): Present
Read the official record for S08196
See everything up for a vote · This week in New York · See what we have filed with the clerk