Lowers evidence standard for disciplinary hearings

File S06727 ("Lowers evidence standard for disciplinary hearings") is before the New York Legislature and has not been decided. Latest step (March 4, 2026): ADVANCED TO THIRD READING.

New York file S06727, before the New York Legislature. Still to be decided as of 2026-03-04.

What it does

Disciplinary cases now need less proof to win Disciplinary and evidentiary hearings will shift from requiring "substantial evidence" (a higher bar) to "preponderance of the evidence" (more-likely-than-not), making it easier for agencies to uphold penalties against public employees, licensees, and regulated professionals.

The bigger picture

Public sector workforce faces weaker due-process protections State agencies, professional licensing boards, and public employers will win disciplinary cases more often, shifting the balance away from employee-protective evidentiary standards that have historically required stronger factual support for adverse actions.

What to watch

Accused workers lose stronger protection against weak evidence Employees and licensees facing discipline will find it harder to challenge findings based on marginal or disputed evidence, and appeal courts will review these lowered-standard decisions with deference to the hearing officer's factual findings.

Read the official record for S06727

See everything up for a vote · This week in New York · See what we have filed with the clerk