Allows direct lawsuits against third-party defendants
File S05170 ("Allows direct lawsuits against third-party defendants") was vetoed. Last action: December 19, 2025.
New York file S05170, before the New York Legislature. Vetoed as of 2025-12-19.
What it does
Sue the actual party responsible for your harm Instead of suing only the business that directly harmed you, you can now sue a third party that the defendant is liable to, potentially reaching deeper pockets or the actual wrongdoer in chain-of-liability situations.
The bigger picture
Shifts incentives for businesses to monitor contractors Companies may face increased liability exposure for harms caused by contractors, vendors, or other third parties they work with, potentially leading to stricter vetting and insurance requirements across supply chains.
What to watch
May increase frivolous litigation and insurance costs Opening direct claims against third parties could expand lawsuit volume and complexity, raising insurance premiums and litigation expenses for small businesses and service providers, and creating new opportunities for defendants to assert that plaintiffs lacked a direct relationship with them.
How they voted
Yes (131)
- Stacey Pheffer Amato (D, HD 23)
- Khaleel M. Anderson (D, HD 31)
- Jamaal Bailey (D, SD 36)
- Didi Barrett (D, HD 106)
- April Baskin (D, SD 63)
- Michael Benedetto (D, HD 82)
- Alex Bores (D, HD 73)
- Edward C. Braunstein (D, HD 26)
- Jabari Brisport (D, SD 25)
- Harry B. Bronson (D, HD 138)
- Samra Brouk (D, SD 55)
- Chris Burdick (D, HD 93)
- Patrick Burke (D, HD 142)
- Noah Burroughs (D, HD 18)
- Siela Bynoe (D, SD 6)
- Patrick J. Carroll (D, HD 96)
- Robert C. Carroll (D, HD 44)
- Monique Chandler-Waterman (D, HD 58)
- Sarah Clark (D, HD 136)
- Cordell Cleare (D, SD 30)
- William Colton (D, HD 47)
- Leroy Comrie (D, SD 14)
- William Conrad (D, HD 140)
- Jeremy Cooney (D, SD 56)
- Catalina Cruz (D, HD 39)
- Brian Cunningham (D, HD 43)
- Landon C. Dais (D, HD 77)
- Erik M. Dilan (D, HD 54)
- Jeffrey Dinowitz (D, HD 81)
- Chris Eachus (D, HD 99)
- Simcha Eichenstein (D, HD 48)
- Harvey Epstein (D)
- Patricia Fahy (D, SD 46)
- Nathalia Fernandez (D, SD 34)
- Phara Souffrant Forrest (D, HD 57)
- Emily Gallagher (D, HD 50)
- Patrick M. Gallivan (R, SD 60)
- Michael Gianaris (D, SD 12)
- Edward Gibbs (D, HD 68)
- Deborah J. Glick (D, HD 66)
- Kristen Gonzalez (D, SD 59)
- Jessica González-Rojas (D, HD 34)
- Andrew Gounardes (D, SD 26)
- Judy Griffin (D, HD 21)
- Pete Harckham (D, SD 40)
- Carl E. Heastie (D, HD 83)
- Pamela Helming (R, SD 54)
- Rodneyse Bichotte Hermelyn (D, HD 42)
- Michelle Hinchey (D, SD 41)
- Larinda C. Hooks (D, HD 35)
- Brad Hoylman-Sigal (D, SD 47)
- Pamela J. Hunter (D, HD 128)
- Alicia Hyndman (D, HD 29)
- John T. McDonald III (D, HD 108)
- Chantel Jackson (D, HD 79)
- Robert Jackson (D, SD 31)
- Jonathan G. Jacobson (D, HD 104)
- Jr. John Zaccaro (D, HD 80)
- D. Billy Jones (D)
- James Sanders Jr. (D, SD 10)
- Rebecca Kassay (D, HD 4)
- Brian Kavanagh (D, SD 27)
- Paula Elaine Kay (HD 100)
- Dr. Anna R. Kelles (D, HD 125)
- Ron Kim (D, HD 40)
- Liz Krueger (D, SD 28)
- Micah C. Lasher (D, HD 69)
- Charles D. Lavine (D, HD 13)
- Grace Lee (D, HD 65)
- Dana Levenberg (D, HD 95)
- John Liu (D, SD 16)
- Nikki Lucas (D, HD 60)
- Jen Lunsford (D, HD 135)
- Donna A. Lupardo (D, HD 123)
- Monica Martinez (D, SD 4)
- Rachel May (D, SD 48)
- Shelley Mayer (D, SD 37)
- Demond Meeks (D, HD 137)
- Marcela Mitaynes (D, HD 51)
- Angelo J. Morinello (R, HD 145)
- Kwani B. O'Pharrow (D, HD 11)
- Steven Otis (D, HD 91)
- Anthony H. Palumbo (R, SD 1)
- Kevin S. Parker (D, SD 21)
- Amy Paulin (D, HD 88)
- Crystal D. Peoples-Stokes (D, HD 141)
- Roxanne J. Persaud (D, SD 19)
- J. Gary Pretlow (D, HD 89)
- Steven Raga (D, HD 30)
- Jenifer Rajkumar (D, HD 38)
- Phil Ramos (D, HD 6)
- Karines Reyes (D, HD 87)
- Steve Rhoads (R, SD 5)
- Gustavo Rivera (D, SD 33)
- Jonathan Rivera (D, HD 149)
- Gabriella A. Romero (D, HD 109)
- Linda B. Rosenthal (D, HD 67)
- Christopher Ryan (D, SD 50)
- Sean Ryan (D, SD 61)
- Julia Salazar (D, SD 18)
- Angelo Santabarbara (D, HD 111)
- Manny De Los Santos (D, HD 72)
- Jessica Scarcella-Spanton (D, SD 23)
- Tommy John Schiavoni (D, HD 1)
- Amanda Septimo (D, HD 84)
- Luis R. Sepúlveda (D, SD 32)
- José M. Serrano (D, SD 29)
- MaryJane Shimsky (D, HD 92)
- Sarahana Shrestha (D, HD 103)
- Jo Anne Simon (D, HD 52)
- Tony Simone (D, HD 75)
- James Skoufis (D, SD 42)
- Michaelle C. Solages (D, HD 22)
- Toby Ann Stavisky (D, SD 11)
- Phil Steck (D, HD 110)
- Steve Stern (D, HD 10)
- Andrea Stewart-Cousins (D, SD 35)
- Al Stirpe (D, HD 127)
- Yudelka Tapia (D, HD 86)
- Al Taylor (D, HD 71)
- James Tedisco (R, SD 44)
- Claire Valdez (D, HD 37)
- Latrice M. Walker (HD 55)
- Lea Webb (D, SD 52)
- David I. Weprin (D, HD 24)
- Aron Wieder (D, HD 97)
- Jaime R. Williams (D, HD 59)
- Carrie Woerner (D, HD 113)
- Jordan J.G. Wright (D, HD 70)
- Kalman Yeger (D, HD 41)
- Stefani Zinerman (D, HD 56)
No (62)
- Joe Angelino (R, HD 121)
- Jr. Anil Beephan (R, HD 105)
- Jake Ashby (R, SD 43)
- Andrea K. Bailey (R, HD 133)
- William A. Barclay (R, HD 120)
- Scott Bendett (R, HD 107)
- Ken Blankenbush (R, HD 117)
- Jake Blumencranz (R, HD 15)
- Paul A. Bologna (R, HD 144)
- George Borrello (R, SD 57)
- Karl Brabenec (R, HD 98)
- Alec Brook-Krasny (R, HD 46)
- Ari Brown (R, HD 20)
- Keith P. Brown (R, HD 12)
- Marianne Buttenschon (D, HD 119)
- Patricia Canzoneri-Fitzpatrick (R, SD 9)
- Stephen T. Chan (R, SD 17)
- Lester Chang (R, HD 49)
- Patrick J. Chludzinski (R, HD 143)
- Joe DeStefano (R, HD 3)
- David DiPietro (R, HD 147)
- Michael Durso (R, HD 9)
- Michael J. Fitzpatrick (R, HD 8)
- Christopher S. Friend (R, HD 124)
- Jeff Gallahan (R, HD 131)
- Jarett Gandolfo (R, HD 7)
- Jodi Giglio (R, HD 2)
- Scott Gray (R, HD 116)
- Joseph A. Griffo (R, SD 53)
- Stephen Hawley (R, HD 139)
- Josh Jensen (R, HD 134)
- Andrew J. Lanza (R, SD 24)
- Brian Maher (R, HD 101)
- Brian Manktelow (R, HD 130)
- Jack M. Martins (R, SD 7)
- Mario Mattera (R, SD 2)
- David G. McDonough (R, HD 14)
- John K. Mikulin (R, HD 17)
- Brian D. Miller (R, HD 122)
- Andrew M. Molitor (R, HD 150)
- Daniel J. Norber (R, HD 16)
- Michael Novakhov (R, HD 45)
- Thomas F. O'Mara (R, SD 58)
- Peter Oberacker (R, SD 51)
- Robert Ortt (R, SD 62)
- Philip A. Palmesano (R, HD 132)
- Sam Pirozzolo (R, HD 63)
- Edward P. Ra (R, HD 19)
- Michael Reilly (R, HD 62)
- Robert Rolison (R, SD 39)
- Joe Sempolinski (R, HD 148)
- Matthew Simpson (R, HD 114)
- Matt Slater (R, HD 94)
- Doug Smith (R, HD 5)
- Robert Smullen (R, HD 118)
- Dan Stec (R, SD 45)
- Chris Tague (R, HD 102)
- Clyde Vanel (D, HD 33)
- Mark Walczyk (R, SD 49)
- Mary Beth Walsh (R, HD 112)
- William Weber (R, SD 38)
- Alexis Weik (R, SD 8)
Did not vote / other (20)
- George Alvarez (D, HD 78): Present
- Sam Berger (D, HD 27): Present
- Vivian E. Cook (D, HD 32): Present
- Maritza Davila (D, HD 53): Present
- Charles D. Fall (D, HD 61): Present
- Andrew Hevesi (D, HD 28): Present
- Joseph P. Addabbo Jr. (D, SD 15): Present
- John Lemondes (R, HD 126): Present
- William B. Magnarelli (D, HD 129): Present
- Zohran Kwame Mamdani (D): Present
- Karen McMahon (D, HD 146): Present
- Dean Murray (R, SD 3): Present
- Zellnor Myrie (D, SD 20): Present
- Jessica Ramos (D, SD 13): Present
- Nily Rozic (D, HD 25): Present
- Nader J. Sayegh (D, HD 90): Present
- Rebecca A. Seawright (D, HD 76): Present
- Sam Sutton (D, SD 22): Present
- Michael Tannousis (R, HD 64): Present
- Emérita Torres (D, HD 85): Present
Read the official record for S05170
See everything up for a vote · This week in New York · See what we have filed with the clerk