Lets insurers cancel policies for staged accidents
File S05052 ("Lets insurers cancel policies for staged accidents") is before the New York Legislature and has not been decided. Latest step (February 9, 2026): referred to insurance.
New York file S05052, before the New York Legislature. Still to be decided as of 2026-02-09.
What it does
Your claim could be denied if insurer finds accident was staged If an insurer determines you were party to a staged accident to collect insurance proceeds, it can cancel your policy retroactively and deny all claims related to that incident.
The bigger picture
Insurance premiums may stabilize as fraud costs decline By enabling retroactive cancellation in fraud cases, insurers reduce their exposure to organized fraud rings, potentially moderating premium increases that would otherwise be passed to all policyholders.
What to watch
Innocent parties may face wrongful denials if misidentified Policyholders not involved in fraud could lose coverage if insurers misclassify accidents as staged, and remedying a wrongful cancellation typically requires expensive litigation even when the insured is vindicated.
How they voted
Yes (60)
- Jake Ashby (R, SD 43)
- Jamaal Bailey (D, SD 36)
- April Baskin (D, SD 63)
- George Borrello (R, SD 57)
- Jabari Brisport (D, SD 25)
- Siela Bynoe (D, SD 6)
- Patricia Canzoneri-Fitzpatrick (R, SD 9)
- Stephen T. Chan (R, SD 17)
- Cordell Cleare (D, SD 30)
- Leroy Comrie (D, SD 14)
- Jeremy Cooney (D, SD 56)
- Patricia Fahy (D, SD 46)
- Nathalia Fernandez (D, SD 34)
- Patrick M. Gallivan (R, SD 60)
- Michael Gianaris (D, SD 12)
- Andrew Gounardes (D, SD 26)
- Joseph A. Griffo (R, SD 53)
- Pete Harckham (D, SD 40)
- Pamela Helming (R, SD 54)
- Michelle Hinchey (D, SD 41)
- Brad Hoylman-Sigal (D, SD 47)
- Robert Jackson (D, SD 31)
- James Sanders Jr. (D, SD 10)
- Joseph P. Addabbo Jr. (D, SD 15)
- Brian Kavanagh (D, SD 27)
- Liz Krueger (D, SD 28)
- Andrew J. Lanza (R, SD 24)
- John Liu (D, SD 16)
- Monica Martinez (D, SD 4)
- Jack M. Martins (R, SD 7)
- Mario Mattera (R, SD 2)
- Rachel May (D, SD 48)
- Shelley Mayer (D, SD 37)
- Dean Murray (R, SD 3)
- Zellnor Myrie (D, SD 20)
- Thomas F. O'Mara (R, SD 58)
- Peter Oberacker (R, SD 51)
- Robert Ortt (R, SD 62)
- Anthony H. Palumbo (R, SD 1)
- Kevin S. Parker (D, SD 21)
- Roxanne J. Persaud (D, SD 19)
- Jessica Ramos (D, SD 13)
- Steve Rhoads (R, SD 5)
- Gustavo Rivera (D, SD 33)
- Robert Rolison (R, SD 39)
- Christopher Ryan (D, SD 50)
- Sean Ryan (D, SD 61)
- Julia Salazar (D, SD 18)
- Jessica Scarcella-Spanton (D, SD 23)
- Luis R. Sepúlveda (D, SD 32)
- José M. Serrano (D, SD 29)
- James Skoufis (D, SD 42)
- Toby Ann Stavisky (D, SD 11)
- Dan Stec (R, SD 45)
- Andrea Stewart-Cousins (D, SD 35)
- James Tedisco (R, SD 44)
- Mark Walczyk (R, SD 49)
- Lea Webb (D, SD 52)
- William Weber (R, SD 38)
- Alexis Weik (R, SD 8)
Did not vote / other (3)
Read the official record for S05052
See everything up for a vote · This week in New York · See what we have filed with the clerk