Judicial commission audits bail decisions for bias
File S04957 ("Judicial commission audits bail decisions for bias") is before the New York Legislature and has not been decided. Latest step (January 7, 2026): REFERRED TO JUDICIARY.
New York file S04957, before the New York Legislature. Still to be decided as of 2026-01-07.
What it does
Bail decisions reviewed for racial or gender bias patterns The state judicial conduct commission will analyze bail data to identify judges whose patterns suggest bias, potentially leading to investigations or public findings that could affect your case outcome or bail terms.
The bigger picture
Data transparency on judicial conduct shapes system accountability Systematic bail data review creates a public record of judicial patterns, which may influence legislative reforms, bail policy changes, and judicial appointments or discipline across the state.
What to watch
Data analysis alone cannot guarantee bias detection or remedy Statistical disparities in bail-setting do not automatically prove intentional bias; the commission's investigative capacity and willingness to act on flagged judges will determine whether findings lead to meaningful discipline or systemic change.
How they voted
Yes (40)
- Jake Ashby (R, SD 43)
- Jamaal Bailey (D, SD 36)
- April Baskin (D, SD 63)
- Jabari Brisport (D, SD 25)
- Samra Brouk (D, SD 55)
- Siela Bynoe (D, SD 6)
- Cordell Cleare (D, SD 30)
- Leroy Comrie (D, SD 14)
- Jeremy Cooney (D, SD 56)
- Patricia Fahy (D, SD 46)
- Nathalia Fernandez (D, SD 34)
- Michael Gianaris (D, SD 12)
- Kristen Gonzalez (D, SD 59)
- Andrew Gounardes (D, SD 26)
- Pete Harckham (D, SD 40)
- Michelle Hinchey (D, SD 41)
- Brad Hoylman-Sigal (D, SD 47)
- Robert Jackson (D, SD 31)
- James Sanders Jr. (D, SD 10)
- Joseph P. Addabbo Jr. (D, SD 15)
- Brian Kavanagh (D, SD 27)
- Liz Krueger (D, SD 28)
- John Liu (D, SD 16)
- Monica Martinez (D, SD 4)
- Mario Mattera (R, SD 2)
- Rachel May (D, SD 48)
- Shelley Mayer (D, SD 37)
- Kevin S. Parker (D, SD 21)
- Roxanne J. Persaud (D, SD 19)
- Gustavo Rivera (D, SD 33)
- Christopher Ryan (D, SD 50)
- Sean Ryan (D, SD 61)
- Julia Salazar (D, SD 18)
- Jessica Scarcella-Spanton (D, SD 23)
- Luis R. Sepúlveda (D, SD 32)
- José M. Serrano (D, SD 29)
- James Skoufis (D, SD 42)
- Toby Ann Stavisky (D, SD 11)
- Andrea Stewart-Cousins (D, SD 35)
- Lea Webb (D, SD 52)
No (19)
- George Borrello (R, SD 57)
- Patricia Canzoneri-Fitzpatrick (R, SD 9)
- Stephen T. Chan (R, SD 17)
- Patrick M. Gallivan (R, SD 60)
- Joseph A. Griffo (R, SD 53)
- Pamela Helming (R, SD 54)
- Andrew J. Lanza (R, SD 24)
- Dean Murray (R, SD 3)
- Thomas F. O'Mara (R, SD 58)
- Peter Oberacker (R, SD 51)
- Robert Ortt (R, SD 62)
- Anthony H. Palumbo (R, SD 1)
- Steve Rhoads (R, SD 5)
- Robert Rolison (R, SD 39)
- Dan Stec (R, SD 45)
- James Tedisco (R, SD 44)
- Mark Walczyk (R, SD 49)
- William Weber (R, SD 38)
- Alexis Weik (R, SD 8)
Did not vote / other (3)
Read the official record for S04957
See everything up for a vote · This week in New York · See what we have filed with the clerk