Bans long-term residential real estate service contracts
File A05886 ("Bans long-term residential real estate service contracts") is before the New York Legislature and has not been decided. Latest step (June 13, 2025): substituted by s6361b.
New York file A05886, before the New York Legislature. No action in 522 days as of 2025-06-13.
What it does
You can't be locked into real estate services beyond two years If you sign a residential real estate service agreement (such as property management, maintenance, or listing contracts), the contract cannot legally require performance more than two years out, preventing long-term lock-in arrangements.
The bigger picture
Real estate service market shifts toward shorter renewal cycles Service providers will need to restructure contracts to renew every two years or less, increasing transaction frequency and potentially raising administrative costs that may be passed to consumers.
What to watch
Vague scope leaves gaps in which services are covered The bill defines unfair agreements only by duration, not by listing specific service types (e.g., property management, HOA contracts, home warranty plans), leaving uncertainty about which residential real estate service agreements fall under the prohibition and creating enforcement inconsistency.
How they voted
Yes (52)
- George Alvarez (D, HD 78)
- Joe Angelino (R, HD 121)
- William A. Barclay (R, HD 120)
- Michael Benedetto (D, HD 82)
- Ken Blankenbush (R, HD 117)
- Jake Blumencranz (R, HD 15)
- Alex Bores (D, HD 73)
- Karl Brabenec (R, HD 98)
- Edward C. Braunstein (D, HD 26)
- Harry B. Bronson (D, HD 138)
- Robert C. Carroll (D, HD 44)
- William Colton (D, HD 47)
- Vivian E. Cook (D, HD 32)
- Catalina Cruz (D, HD 39)
- Brian Cunningham (D, HD 43)
- Maritza Davila (D, HD 53)
- Jeffrey Dinowitz (D, HD 81)
- Harvey Epstein (D)
- Phara Souffrant Forrest (D, HD 57)
- Emily Gallagher (D, HD 50)
- Deborah J. Glick (D, HD 66)
- Stephen Hawley (R, HD 139)
- Andrew Hevesi (D, HD 28)
- Pamela J. Hunter (D, HD 128)
- Alicia Hyndman (D, HD 29)
- Josh Jensen (R, HD 134)
- Micah C. Lasher (D, HD 69)
- Charles D. Lavine (D, HD 13)
- Grace Lee (D, HD 65)
- Donna A. Lupardo (D, HD 123)
- William B. Magnarelli (D, HD 129)
- John K. Mikulin (R, HD 17)
- Andrew M. Molitor (R, HD 150)
- Angelo J. Morinello (R, HD 145)
- Philip A. Palmesano (R, HD 132)
- Amy Paulin (D, HD 88)
- Crystal D. Peoples-Stokes (D, HD 141)
- J. Gary Pretlow (D, HD 89)
- Edward P. Ra (R, HD 19)
- Jenifer Rajkumar (D, HD 38)
- Michael Reilly (R, HD 62)
- Karines Reyes (D, HD 87)
- Gabriella A. Romero (D, HD 109)
- Linda B. Rosenthal (D, HD 67)
- Nily Rozic (D, HD 25)
- Rebecca A. Seawright (D, HD 76)
- Doug Smith (R, HD 5)
- Michael Tannousis (R, HD 64)
- Al Taylor (D, HD 71)
- Emérita Torres (D, HD 85)
- Latrice M. Walker (HD 55)
- David I. Weprin (D, HD 24)
No (3)
Did not vote / other (3)
Read the official record for A05886
See everything up for a vote · This week in New York · See what we have filed with the clerk