Judges gain discretion, sentences increase, policing rules ease

File A04754 ("Judges gain discretion, sentences increase, policing rules ease") is before the New York Legislature and has not been decided. Latest step (January 7, 2026): referred to codes.

New York file A04754, before the New York Legislature. Still to be decided as of 2026-01-07.

What it does

Longer prison terms and stricter bail conditions for defendants Judges gain discretion to impose longer sentences and set tougher bail restrictions; defendants face fewer procedural opportunities to challenge convictions or access evidence during discovery.

The bigger picture

Police accountability standards weakened across enforcement practices Repealing use-of-force and premises-access provisions reduces legal guardrails on how officers conduct searches and apply physical force, shifting enforcement discretion toward law enforcement with less judicial oversight.

What to watch

Defendants lose tools to challenge wrongful convictions Limiting motions to vacate and discovery access reduces pathways to exonerate innocent people or correct procedural errors, and the shift to judicial discretion on securing orders may widen disparities based on judge assignment and local practice variation.

How they voted

Yes (16)

No (6)

Read the official record for A04754

See everything up for a vote · This week in New York · See what we have filed with the clerk