Protects right to speak at sentencing despite waiver

File A03524 ("Protects right to speak at sentencing despite waiver") is before the New York Legislature and has not been decided. Latest step (March 12, 2026): advanced to third reading cal.289.

New York file A03524, before the New York Legislature. Still to be decided as of 2026-03-12.

What it does

You can appeal sentencing if silenced, waiver or not If you were prevented from making a personal statement at sentencing, you can now appeal that violation even if you signed a waiver giving up other appeal rights.

The bigger picture

Appellate courts will review more sentencing procedures Courts will see increased appeals challenging whether defendants were actually given their statutory right to speak before sentencing, creating new precedent on procedural fairness.

What to watch

May lengthen case timelines and court dockets Prosecutors and trial courts warn this exception to waiver agreements could generate additional appeals, potentially delaying finality in criminal cases and adding administrative burden.

How they voted

Yes (13)

No (6)

Did not vote / other (3)

Read the official record for A03524

See everything up for a vote · This week in New York · See what we have filed with the clerk