Arbitration firms must disclose dispute data publicly
File A03318 ("Arbitration firms must disclose dispute data publicly") is before the New York Legislature and has not been decided. Latest step (January 7, 2026): ordered to third reading cal.106.
New York file A03318, before the New York Legislature. Still to be decided as of 2026-01-07.
What it does
Access searchable arbitration outcomes and fairness metrics Consumers involved in arbitration disputes can search a public database for quarterly-updated information on how similar cases were resolved, winning rates, and awards—helping you understand your own case's likely outcome before or during the process.
The bigger picture
Market pressure may improve arbitration firm practices Public disclosure of dispute patterns and financial conflicts of interest creates reputational incentives for arbitration firms to handle cases more fairly, potentially shifting how companies design arbitration clauses in consumer contracts.
What to watch
Small arbitrators and niche disputes remain opaque Organizations handling fewer than 50 consumer arbitrations per year are exempt from disclosure requirements, leaving a gap for consumers in specialized or regional arbitration markets.
How they voted
Yes (36)
- George Alvarez (D, HD 78)
- Alex Bores (D, HD 73)
- Edward C. Braunstein (D, HD 26)
- Harry B. Bronson (D, HD 138)
- Robert C. Carroll (D, HD 44)
- William Colton (D, HD 47)
- Vivian E. Cook (D, HD 32)
- Catalina Cruz (D, HD 39)
- Brian Cunningham (D, HD 43)
- Maritza Davila (D, HD 53)
- Jeffrey Dinowitz (D, HD 81)
- Harvey Epstein (D)
- Phara Souffrant Forrest (D, HD 57)
- Emily Gallagher (D, HD 50)
- Deborah J. Glick (D, HD 66)
- Andrew Hevesi (D, HD 28)
- Pamela J. Hunter (D, HD 128)
- Alicia Hyndman (D, HD 29)
- Micah C. Lasher (D, HD 69)
- Charles D. Lavine (D, HD 13)
- Grace Lee (D, HD 65)
- Donna A. Lupardo (D, HD 123)
- Amy Paulin (D, HD 88)
- Crystal D. Peoples-Stokes (D, HD 141)
- J. Gary Pretlow (D, HD 89)
- Jenifer Rajkumar (D, HD 38)
- Karines Reyes (D, HD 87)
- Gabriella A. Romero (D, HD 109)
- Linda B. Rosenthal (D, HD 67)
- Nily Rozic (D, HD 25)
- Rebecca A. Seawright (D, HD 76)
- Al Taylor (D, HD 71)
- Emérita Torres (D, HD 85)
- Clyde Vanel (D, HD 33)
- Latrice M. Walker (HD 55)
- David I. Weprin (D, HD 24)
No (18)
- Joe Angelino (R, HD 121)
- William A. Barclay (R, HD 120)
- Ken Blankenbush (R, HD 117)
- Jake Blumencranz (R, HD 15)
- Paul A. Bologna (R, HD 144)
- Karl Brabenec (R, HD 98)
- Michael Durso (R, HD 9)
- Stephen Hawley (R, HD 139)
- Josh Jensen (R, HD 134)
- John K. Mikulin (R, HD 17)
- Brian D. Miller (R, HD 122)
- Andrew M. Molitor (R, HD 150)
- Angelo J. Morinello (R, HD 145)
- Philip A. Palmesano (R, HD 132)
- Edward P. Ra (R, HD 19)
- Michael Reilly (R, HD 62)
- Doug Smith (R, HD 5)
- Michael Tannousis (R, HD 64)
Did not vote / other (4)
Read the official record for A03318
See everything up for a vote · This week in New York · See what we have filed with the clerk