Allows extra jury challenges in tied defendant cases

The New York Legislature approved file A00934 ("Allows extra jury challenges in tied defendant cases"), by a recorded vote of 195 to 0. Last action: October 16, 2025.

New York file A00934, before the New York Legislature. Passed as of 2025-10-16.

What it does

Defendants gain one extra peremptory challenge in deadlock situations When an even number of co-defendants cannot agree on jury composition, this bill guarantees each defendant at least one additional challenge to remove a prospective juror without stating cause.

The bigger picture

Affects jury composition outcomes in multi-defendant criminal trials By enabling additional strikes when co-defendants disagree, the rule shifts jury makeup slightly away from prosecution-preferred panels and may lengthen voir dire in cases with multiple defendants.

What to watch

May further limit juror diversity and trial duration unpredictably Expanding peremptory challenges—even conditionally—risks reducing representation of demographic groups prosecutors and defendants both disfavor; courts also project longer jury-selection periods, increasing case backlogs and trial costs.

How they voted

Yes (195)

Did not vote / other (18)

Read the official record for A00934

See everything up for a vote · This week in New York · See what we have filed with the clerk