Guarantees right to insurance claim appraisal
The Illinois Legislature approved file HB4160 ("Guarantees right to insurance claim appraisal"), by a recorded vote of 169 to 2. Last action: August 7, 2026.
Illinois file HB4160, before the Illinois Legislature. Passed as of 2026-08-07.
What it does
Dispute an insurer's damage estimate through binding appraisal If your insurer's valuation of your car damage or total loss disagrees with yours, you can invoke appraisal—either party selects an appraiser, and if they disagree, an umpire decides—with the award binding on both sides.
The bigger picture
Reduces litigation by offering faster damage resolution path Appraisal provides a streamlined alternative to small claims court or negotiation, potentially lowering dispute costs for both consumers and insurers while creating a new advisory board to shape fair claim standards across the state.
Official summary
Amends the Illinois Insurance Code. Provides that every automobile insurance policy issued, renewed, or delivered in Illinois that includes first-party coverage for physical damage shall contain a provision granting either the insured or the insurer the right to invoke appraisal in the event of a dispute over (i) the actual cash value or amount of a loss, including repairable or total loss amounts; or (ii) the value of a settlement offer made to a third-party claimant. Sets forth provisions concerning the selection of appraisers; appointment of an umpire in the event of a disagreement between appraisers; issuance of the award following the appraisal; the binding effect of an agreement between appraisers or one appraiser and the umpire; cost allocation and consumer protections; the right of appraisal for third-party claimants; and enforcement and penalties. Creates the Automotive Appraisal Standards Advisory Board to provide guidance on rulemaking, enforcement priorities, and best practices. Sets forth membership provisions and provides that the Board shall meet no less than quarterly and may issue nonbinding recommendations to the Department of Insurance regarding updates to rules
How they voted
Yes (169)
- Carol Ammons (D, HD 103)
- Neil Anderson (R, SD 47)
- Jaime Andrade (D, HD 40)
- Omar Aquino (D, SD 2)
- Li Arellano (R, SD 37)
- Dee Avelar (D, HD 85)
- Chris Balkema (R, SD 53)
- Christopher Belt (D, SD 57)
- Diane Blair-Sherlock (D, HD 46)
- Murri Briel (D, HD 76)
- Terri Bryant (R, SD 58)
- Kam Buckner (D, HD 26)
- Kimberly Du Buclet (D, HD 5)
- Jason Bunting (R, HD 106)
- John Cabello (R, HD 90)
- Mary Beth Canty (D, HD 54)
- Meg Loughran Cappel (D, SD 49)
- Kelly Cassidy (D, HD 14)
- Cristina Castro (D, SD 22)
- Javier Cervantes (D, SD 1)
- Sharon Chung (D, HD 91)
- Justin Cochran (D, HD 55)
- Mike Coffey (R, HD 95)
- Lakesia Collins (D, SD 5)
- Mike Crawford (D, HD 31)
- Fred Crespo (D, HD 44)
- Margaret Croke (D, HD 12)
- Bill Cunningham (D, SD 18)
- John Curran (R, SD 41)
- C.D. Davidsmeyer (R, HD 100)
- Jed Davis (R, HD 75)
- Lisa Davis (D, HD 32)
- Will Davis (D, HD 30)
- Regan Deering (R, HD 88)
- Margaret DeLaRosa (D, HD 42)
- Eva-Dina Delgado (D, HD 3)
- Anthony DeLuca (D, HD 80)
- Marti Deuter (D, HD 45)
- Don DeWitte (R, SD 33)
- Laura Faver Dias (D, HD 62)
- Dan Didech (D, HD 59)
- Scott Doody (R, HD 118)
- Mary Edly-Allen (D, SD 31)
- Amy Elik (R, HD 111)
- Laura Ellman (D, SD 21)
- Marcus Evans (D, HD 33)
- Paul Faraci (D, SD 52)
- Sara Feigenholtz (D, SD 6)
- Laura Fine (D, SD 9)
- La Shawn Ford (D, HD 8)
- David Friess (R, HD 115)
- Brad Fritts (R, HD 74)
- Robyn Gabel (D, HD 18)
- Mary Gill (D, HD 35)
- Jen Gong-Gershowitz (D, HD 17)
- Edgar González (D, HD 23)
- Jehan Gordon-Booth (D, HD 92)
- Amy Grant (R, HD 47)
- Nicolle Grasse (D, HD 53)
- Angie Guerrero-Cuellar (D, HD 22)
- Graciela Guzmán (D, SD 20)
- Will Guzzardi (D, HD 39)
- Nicole La Ha (R, HD 82)
- Jackie Haas (R, HD 79)
- Mike Halpin (D, SD 36)
- Norine Hammond (R, HD 94)
- Matt Hanson (D, HD 83)
- Sonya Harper (D, HD 6)
- Napoleon Harris (D, SD 15)
- Erica Harriss (R, SD 56)
- Mike Hastings (D, SD 19)
- Bill Hauter (R, HD 87)
- Jessica Dixon Heitman (D, HD 97)
- Barbara Hernandez (D, HD 50)
- Lisa Hernandez (D, HD 2)
- Norma Hernandez (D, HD 77)
- Darby Hills (R, SD 26)
- Suzy Glowiak Hilton (D, SD 23)
- Maura Hirschauer (D, HD 49)
- Jay Hoffman (D, HD 113)
- Linda Holmes (D, SD 42)
- Mattie Hunter (D, SD 3)
- Hoan Huynh (D, HD 13)
- Paul Jacobs (R, SD 59)
- Lilian Jiménez (D, HD 4)
- Adriane Johnson (D, SD 30)
- Gregg Johnson (D, HD 72)
- Emil Jones (D, SD 14)
- Thaddeus Jones (D, HD 29)
- Patrick Joyce (D, SD 40)
- Jeff Keicher (R, HD 70)
- Michael Kelly (D, HD 15)
- Stephanie Kifowit (D, HD 84)
- Dave Koehler (D, SD 46)
- Lindsey LaPointe (D, HD 19)
- Kimberly Lightford (D, SD 4)
- Camille Lilly (D, HD 78)
- Theresa Mah (D, HD 24)
- Natalie Manley (D, HD 98)
- Rob Martwick (D, SD 10)
- Rita Mayfield (D, HD 60)
- Steve McClure (R, SD 54)
- Tony McCombie (R, HD 89)
- Marty McLaughlin (R, HD 52)
- Charlie Meier (R, HD 109)
- Debbie Meyers-Martin (D, HD 38)
- Anna Moeller (D, HD 43)
- Kyle Moore (R, HD 99)
- Bob Morgan (D, HD 58)
- Yolonda Morris (D, HD 9)
- Julie Morrison (D, SD 29)
- Tracy Katz Muhl (D, HD 57)
- Laura Murphy (D, SD 28)
- Michelle Mussman (D, HD 56)
- Suzanne Ness (D, HD 66)
- Adam Niemerg (R, HD 102)
- Kevin Olickal (D, HD 16)
- Aarón Ortíz (D, HD 1)
- Robert Peters (D, SD 13)
- Mike Porfirio (D, SD 11)
- Willie Preston (D, SD 16)
- Abdelnasser Rashid (D, HD 21)
- Steve Reick (R, HD 63)
- Sue Rezin (R, SD 38)
- Bob Rita (D, HD 28)
- Janet Yang Rohr (D, HD 41)
- Chapin Rose (R, SD 51)
- Wayne Rosenthal (R, HD 108)
- Rick Ryan (D, HD 36)
- Jennifer Sanalitro (R, HD 48)
- Sue Scherer (D, HD 96)
- Kevin Schmidt (R, HD 114)
- Brandun Schweizer (R, HD 104)
- Dave Severin (R, HD 116)
- Patrick Sheehan (R, HD 37)
- Mike Simmons (D, SD 7)
- Elgie Sims (D, SD 17)
- Justin Slaughter (D, HD 27)
- Nick Smith (D, HD 34)
- Joe Sosnowski (R, HD 69)
- Ryan Spain (R, HD 73)
- Steve Stadelman (D, SD 34)
- Anne Stava (D, HD 81)
- Brad Stephens (R, HD 20)
- Katie Stuart (D, HD 112)
- Dan Swanson (R, HD 71)
- Nabeela Syed (D, HD 51)
- Dave Syverson (R, SD 35)
- Curtis Tarver (D, HD 25)
- Dennis Tipsword (R, HD 105)
- Jil Tracy (R, SD 50)
- Doris Turner (D, SD 48)
- Sally Turner (R, SD 44)
- Dan Ugaste (R, HD 65)
- Dave Vella (D, HD 68)
- Rachel Ventura (D, SD 43)
- Karina Villa (D, SD 25)
- Celina Villanueva (D, SD 12)
- Ram Villivalam (D, SD 8)
- Mark Walker (D, SD 27)
- Larry Walsh (D, HD 86)
- Travis Weaver (R, HD 93)
- Tom Weber (R, HD 64)
- Maurice West (D, HD 67)
- Craig Wilcox (R, SD 32)
- Blaine Wilhour (R, HD 110)
- Ann Williams (D, HD 11)
- Omar Williams (D, HD 10)
- Patrick Windhorst (R, HD 117)
No (2)
Did not vote / other (4)
Read the official record for HB4160
See everything up for a vote · This week in Illinois · See what we have filed with the clerk