Allows juries to consider lesser related criminal charges
File 202520260SB1173 ("Allows juries to consider lesser related criminal charges") is before the California Legislature and has not been decided. Latest step (September 27, 2026): In Senate. Consideration of Governor's veto pending.
California file 202520260SB1173, before the California Legislature. Still to be decided as of 2026-09-27.
What it does
Juries gain option to convict on lesser included offenses If you're on a jury in a California criminal trial, you may now have the explicit option to find a defendant guilty of a related lesser crime even if the prosecution charged a more serious offense, rather than choosing only guilty or not guilty on the original charge.
The bigger picture
May reduce hung juries and acquittals in serious cases By giving jurors a middle-ground verdict option, the law could decrease deadlocked trials and acquittals where jurors disagree on guilt for the top charge but might agree on a lesser offense, potentially increasing overall conviction rates on some charge.
What to watch
Defendants lose jury buffer for overcharging by prosecutors Defense advocates warn that expanding lesser-included offense instructions may penalize defendants charged with aggravated crimes, since jurors can now convict on a reduced charge even when they harbor reasonable doubt about the main charge—potentially replacing full acquittals with partial convictions.
How they voted
Yes (76)
- Cecilia Aguiar-Curry (D, HD 4)
- Patrick Ahrens (D, HD 26)
- Benjamin Allen (D, SD 24)
- David Alvarez (D, HD 80)
- Joaquin Arambula (D, HD 31)
- Bob Archuleta (D, SD 30)
- Jesse Arreguín (D, SD 7)
- Angelique Ashby (D, SD 8)
- Rebecca Bauer-Kahan (D, HD 16)
- Josh Becker (D, SD 13)
- Steve Bennett (D, HD 38)
- Marc Berman (D, HD 23)
- Catherine Blakespear (D, SD 38)
- Mia Bonta (D, HD 18)
- Isaac Bryan (D, HD 55)
- Christopher Cabaldon (D, SD 3)
- Anna Caballero (D, SD 14)
- Lisa Calderon (D, HD 56)
- Jessica Caloza (D, HD 52)
- Juan Carrillo (D, HD 39)
- Sabrina Cervantes (D, SD 31)
- Damon Connolly (D, HD 12)
- Dave Cortese (D, SD 15)
- Maria Elena Durazo (D, SD 26)
- Sade Elhawary (D, HD 57)
- Anamarie Ávila Farías (D, HD 15)
- Mike Fong (D, HD 49)
- Robert Garcia (D, HD 50)
- Mike Gipson (D, HD 65)
- Lena Gonzalez (D, SD 33)
- Mark González (D, HD 54)
- Tim Grayson (D, SD 9)
- Matt Haney (D, HD 17)
- John Harabedian (D, HD 41)
- Gregg Hart (D, HD 37)
- Melissa Hurtado (D, SD 16)
- Jacqui Irwin (D, HD 42)
- Corey Jackson (D, HD 60)
- Ash Kalra (D, HD 25)
- Maggy Krell (D, HD 6)
- John Laird (D, SD 17)
- Alex Lee (D, HD 24)
- Monique Limón (D, SD 21)
- Josh Lowenthal (D, HD 69)
- Mike McGuire (D, SD 2)
- Tina McKinnor (D, HD 61)
- Caroline Menjivar (D, SD 20)
- Liz Ortega (D, HD 20)
- Blanca Pacheco (D, HD 64)
- Steve Padilla (D, SD 18)
- Diane Papan (D, HD 21)
- Gail Pellerin (D, HD 28)
- Sasha Pérez (D, SD 25)
- Cottie Petrie-Norris (D, HD 73)
- Akilah Weber Pierson (D, SD 39)
- Sharon Quirk-Silva (D, HD 67)
- James Ramos (D, HD 45)
- Rhodesia Ransom (D, HD 13)
- Eloise Reyes (D, SD 29)
- Laura Richardson (D, SD 35)
- Robert Rivas (D, HD 29)
- Celeste Rodriguez (D, HD 43)
- Chris Rogers (D, HD 2)
- Susan Rubio (D, SD 22)
- Nick Schultz (D, HD 44)
- LaShae Sharp-Collins (D, HD 79)
- Lola Smallwood-Cuevas (D, SD 28)
- José Solache (D, HD 62)
- Esmeralda Soria (D, HD 27)
- Henry Stern (D, SD 27)
- Avelino Valencia (D, HD 68)
- Aisha Wahab (D)
- Buffy Wicks (D, HD 14)
- Scott Wiener (D, SD 11)
- Lori Wilson (D, HD 11)
- Rick Zbur (D, HD 51)
No (30)
- Juan Alanis (R, HD 22)
- Marie Alvarado-Gil (R, SD 4)
- Rosilicie Ochoa Bogh (R, SD 19)
- Leticia Castillo (R, HD 58)
- Phillip Chen (R, HD 59)
- Steven S Choi (R, SD 37)
- Megan Dahle (R, SD 1)
- Laurie Davies (R, HD 74)
- Carl DeMaio (R, HD 75)
- Diane Dixon (R, HD 72)
- Stan Ellis (R, HD 32)
- Heath Flora (R, HD 9)
- Jeff Gonzalez (R, HD 36)
- Shannon Grove (R, SD 12)
- Heather Hadwick (R, HD 1)
- Josh Hoover (R, HD 7)
- Natasha Johnson (R, HD 63)
- Brian Jones (R, SD 40)
- Tom Lackey (R, HD 34)
- Alexandra Macedo (R, HD 33)
- Jerry McNerney (D, SD 5)
- Roger Niello (R, SD 6)
- Joe Patterson (R, HD 5)
- Kate Sanchez (R, HD 71)
- Kelly Seyarto (R, SD 32)
- Tony Strickland (R, SD 36)
- Tri Ta (R, HD 70)
- David Tangipa (R, HD 8)
- Suzette Valladares (R, SD 23)
- Greg Wallis (R, HD 47)
Read the official record for 202520260SB1173
See everything up for a vote · This week in California · See what we have filed with the clerk